Before a wall is planned, the ground has to be chosen, and the classical texts treat that as the heart of the subject. The Manasara gives three of its early chapters to the classification of sites, the examination of the soil and the selection of the plot. The Brihat Samhita fills a long stretch of its chapter on house-building with tests, cautions and small practical observations.
Much of this is ordinary good sense about land. Some of it reflects the assumptions of its age. A little is at odds with what is taught today. This page goes through it plainly, and says where a popular rule has no support in the verses we could read.
Level ground and the question of slope
On slope the Brihat Samhita is clear and also internally tense, and this is where popular Vastu and the verses part company.
The text says that a man who wants prosperity should raise the house ground evenly on all sides, and that if any part is higher than the rest there will be misery; if it cannot be avoided, the east or the north may be slightly higher (53.116). It then says that if the east is higher there will be hatred among friends, if the south is higher there will be deaths in the family, if the west is higher a loss of wealth, and if the north is higher, grief (53.117). The Iyer translation of the preceding verse adds that a higher north-eastern corner brings loss of wealth and sons; the Sastri translation reads that verse as applying to the east or the north generally (the first clause of 53.115, the same verse that carries the irregular-shape warning under Plot shape below).
Read together, the text says four things. Level is best. Every raised side has a caution attached. A small rise to the east or north is the least bad. And the two translations do not quite agree about the north-east corner.
Popular Vastu teaches something different: the ground should fall towards the north-east, with the south-west highest and heaviest. That is a coherent rule and it drains water away from the heavy corner, but it is not what the Brihat Samhita says, which warns against a raised south and a raised west, and we were unable to check what the Mayamata and the Manasara say about slope in the original. The honest summary is that the tradition contains more than one view of slope, and that a slope down towards the north and east is a later, widely taught convention, not the Brihat Samhita’s own.
If you are choosing land, the practical question is simpler and worth more than either rule: where does the rainwater go, and does it go away from the house?
Plot shape
The Brihat Samhita’s verse on shape is short and severe. If the ground is irregular in shape, kinsmen will die; if its sides are irregular, there will be no pregnancy (53.115, Iyer). Sastri has the same verse saying that a plot that is not straight destroys kinsmen, and that one that faces no particular direction leaves a household without children.
The spirit is clear even if the wording is alarming: a regular plot, square or rectangular, squarely oriented, was the ideal. That suits the mandala, which is a grid, and it is also the most buildable kind of plot.
Popular Vastu has built a good deal on this. It grades plots as square, rectangular, round, triangular, L-shaped; it speaks of the cow-faced plot, narrow at the road and wide behind, as good for a home and the lion-faced plot, wide at the road, as better for a business; and it has rules for corners that extend or are cut away, with an extension to the north-east called favourable and a cut in the south-west called serious. Some of this may well be in the texts we did not read, and some of it is certainly in later manuals. We could not trace the cow-faced and lion-faced rule or the corner rules to a verse in the Brihat Samhita or in Acharya’s summary of the Manasara, so they are presented here as commonly taught, not as confirmed classical rules.
What can be said fairly is that an irregular plot is harder to lay out well, and the remedy in practice is to make the building itself regular within the plot and to put the uneven part to a simple use, as a garden or a passage.
Trees, water and neighbours
The Brihat Samhita has several observations that are plainly about livability.
- Thorny trees near a house bring a fear of enemies, milky trees a waste of wealth, and fruit trees the death of children (53.86). The first is a fair caution about thorns and the last reads oddly for a tree planted for fruit; we report it without endorsing it.
- If a tree cannot be removed, plant good trees between, and the text names seven (53.87).
- A house on low ground or near a ditch suffers from thirst, and a nearby anthill with many holes is a danger (53.90). Both are sensible.
- If the house of a minister or a cheat is near, or four roads meet at the site, there is loss of wealth, a bad name or a fear (53.89). A road opposite the gate is a misery unless it is farther than twice the height of the house (53.76).
- One verse cautions against a Buddhist temple nearby (53.90). It reflects the religious rivalries of its time, and this site does not repeat it as guidance.
The verses about trees also give directions, discussed in the page on directions. The verses on felling a tree before building, with an offering the night before and a cut from left to right, belong to the ritual side of the tradition and are not something the site asks anyone to do.
Beginning the work
The text asks that the ground be ploughed first, or sown with grain, or occupied by cows or Brahmins, and that an astrologer choose the hour for entering it (53.98). The first foundation stone goes in the north-east corner and the work proceeds clockwise (53.112). These are the ritual frame that surrounds the building rules and they are still observed in many households as a ceremony, which is a reasonable thing for a household to choose to do.
Classical and modern, in one place
| Claim | Status |
|---|
| Firm, sweet, well-drained soil; tests with a pit | Classical, Brihat Samhita and Manasara |
| Level ground is best; east or north may be a little higher | Classical, Brihat Samhita 53.116 |
| Ground should fall to the north-east, south-west highest | Later convention; not the Brihat Samhita’s rule |
| A regular plot is preferred | Classical in spirit, Brihat Samhita 53.115 |
| Cow-faced and lion-faced plots; extensions and cuts at corners | Commonly taught; not traced to the verses read |
| Care with neighbours, roads and low ground | Classical, Brihat Samhita 53.76 and 53.89 to 53.90 |