Popular rules and what the texts say
Each rule is given as people usually hear it, then the text it is normally traced to, then what that text actually says.
1. “The master bedroom must be in the south-west”
- Usually traced to: the room verse of the Brihat Samhita, the only classical verse that assigns rooms to directions.
- What the text says: “The apartment for the Devas shall be built in the north-east; the kitchen in the south-east; the room for the household utensils shall be erected in the south-west; and the treasury and the granary rooms shall be erected in the north-west” (53.118). The south-west is a store, not a bedroom. Acharya’s summary of the Manasara places the houses of the master, his wife and the children around the family temple at the centre of the compound, and gives no direction for any of them (chapter 36).
- Label: modern. A south-west bedroom is a fine choice. It is not a verse.
2. “Keep the locker or cash box in the north, Kubera’s direction”
- Usually traced to: the guardians of the directions, where Kubera holds the north.
- What the text says: the same room verse puts “the treasury and the granary rooms” in the north-west (53.118). The north is linked with wealth elsewhere in the chapter, through water: a pool in the north brings “increase of wealth” (53.119).
- Label: modern. The one classical treasury verse points to the north-west.
3. “The toilet must be in the north-west or the south, never the north-east”
- Usually traced to: “Vastu Shastra” in general, sometimes to the Brihat Samhita’s water verse.
- What the text says: chapter 53 has no toilet. Its water verse (53.119) is about a pool or piece of water in each direction, with results from loss to increase of wealth. The Manasara summary’s village chapter says drains run in the direction of the slope (chapter 9). Our toilets page goes through this.
- Label: modern. Keeping a toilet away from the shrine and the kitchen is good sense; the direction is convention.
4. “Sleep with your head to the south, because of the earth’s magnetic field”
- Usually traced to: the sleeping verse, with a magnetic reason added.
- What the text says: a person who desires prosperity shall not sleep “with his head towards the north or west, nor naked nor with wet feet”, nor under a beam (53.124). That leaves south and east equally open. The verse gives no reason, and the texts did not use a magnetic compass: the Manasara finds north with a gnomon and the sun’s shadow (chapter 6).
- Label: the rule is classical; “south only” and the magnetic reason are modern. See bedrooms in Vastu.
5. “A south-facing house is bad”
- Usually traced to: the entrance table, the 32 squares on which a door can stand.
- What the text says: the Brihat Samhita gives a result for each of the eight door squares on every wall (53.72 to 53.75). On our reading of that table, the south wall has 1 favourable square, 1 disputed between translators and 6 cautioned. The east wall has 2 favourable and 4 cautioned; the north 3 and 3. No wall is all good or all bad. The Manasara summary prefers a building facing east or north-east and rules out only the south-east (chapter 6).
- Label: modern as a blanket rule. Check the door’s square with the entrance checker, not the side alone.
6. “The north-east must be the lowest corner, the south-west the highest”
- Usually traced to: the slope verses of the Brihat Samhita.
- What the text says: “He that desires prosperity shall raise the house-ground equally on all sides … If unavoidable, the eastern or northern side may be of a slightly higher level” (53.116). The verse before cautions against a north-east corner that is higher than the rest (53.115), and the verse after attaches a result to every side that is higher, east and north included (53.117).
- Label: the classical preference is a level plot. A high south-west is not in these verses.
7. “The staircase must turn clockwise, with an odd number of steps”
- Usually traced to: the foundation verse, where work goes “from left to right”.
- What the text says: “the first foundation stone shall be laid on the north-eastern corner, and then, all round from left to right, the other stones shall be laid. The pillars shall also be erected, in the same order” (53.112). That is the order of laying stones, not the turn of a stair. Acharya’s summary mentions a long account of staircases in the chapters on storeyed buildings (page 23) and records no rule on their turn.
- Label: modern. Our staircase page has the details.
8. “Mirrors may hang only on the north or east wall”
- Usually traced to: “the texts” in general.
- What the text says: chapter 53 has no mirror. The Manasara does describe mirrors, as one of the “external ornaments”: nine sizes, quite circular, with a bright surface and a decorated back (summary, chapter 50). It names no wall and no direction.
- Label: modern. See mirrors in Vastu.
9. “Every direction has its own colour”
- Usually traced to: the elements and the planets of the directions.
- What the text says: chapter 53 has no colour scheme for walls. The only colours in it are of the soil: white, red, yellow or black ground is matched to the four classes of the period (53.96), which is about choosing land, not paint.
- Label: modern.
10. “Water belongs to the north-east, fire to the south-east, earth to the south-west, air to the north-west”
- Usually traced to: the five elements of the old texts.
- What the text says: the building chapter does not set out this map. Two of its verses fit it: the kitchen goes in the south-east (53.118) and water in the north or north-east brings increase (53.119). Earth and air are not given corners.
- Label: a later teaching scheme, as our eight directions page explains.
11. “Vastu divides a home into 16 zones, or 32 directions”
- Usually traced to: the mandala.
- What the text says: the Brihat Samhita divides the ground into 81 squares by ten lines each way (53.42), or into 64 squares (53.55 to 53.56). The Manasara does have a 32, but it is 32 kinds of square grid, from one square up, named one by one (summary, chapter 7). Neither text cuts the compass into 16 or 32 wedges.
- Label: modern. Our Vastu chakra guide shows the zones and where they came from.
12. “Any road or T-junction facing the door is a defect”
- Usually traced to: the verse on obstructions, veedhi shoola.
- What the text says: roads, trees, street corners, wells, pillars or gutters opposite the gate bring misery, but “if these should be beyond a distance of double the height of the house, they will produce no harm” (53.76).
- Label: classical, with a distance limit that popular versions drop. See T-junctions and veedhi shoola.
13. “A peepal tree near the house is always unlucky”
- Usually traced to: the tree verses.
- What the text says: four trees are directional. The ashvattha, the peepal, brings trouble on the east and prosperity on the west, and the banyan, the udumbara and the plaksha each have their own good and bad sides (53.85). If a tree is hard to remove, the text says to grow better trees between it and the house (53.87).
- Label: classical, but by direction, and with a gentle remedy.
14. “A defect needs a yantra, a pyramid or a crystal”
- Usually traced to: “Vastu remedies” in general.
- What the text says: the remedies in these sources are worship and planting. The builder honours the deities of the site “with various cakes, curdled milk, coloured rice, sandal paste, flowers and perfumed smoke” (53.99); offerings are prescribed for each deity of the grid (Manasara summary, chapter 8); and trees can be screened with better trees (53.87). No object is sold.
- Label: modern market. See what the texts say about remedies.
15. “The centre of the house must be open to the sky”
- Usually traced to: the Brahmasthan.
- What the text says: the householder “shall take particular care of the portion of the house which is the seat of Brahma” and keep it free of impurities (53.66), and no pillar should stand on the vital points (53.57). The Manasara summary says the central square is unfit for a dwelling and that the temple of the family god is generally built there (chapter 36).
- Label: keeping the centre set apart is classical. “Open to the sky” is not in these sources. See the Brahmasthan.
16. “The puja room can only be in the north-east”
- Usually traced to: the room verse.
- What the text says: the north-east is right for the gods’ room (53.118). The Manasara summary also places the family temple at the centre of the compound (chapter 36).
- Label: the north-east is classical, but it is not the only classical place.
17. “The main door must face east or north”
- Usually traced to: the Manasara’s orientation rule.
- What the text says: the summary says a building should “preferably face the east or the north-east” and never the south-east (chapter 6). The Brihat Samhita’s table has favourable squares on all four walls, two of them on the west and one on the south (53.72 to 53.75).
- Label: partly classical: a preference, not a ban on west or south.
18. “The cook must face east”
- Usually traced to: the kitchen verse.
- What the text says: the kitchen goes in the south-east (53.118). Which way the cook stands is not in the verse.
- Label: the corner is classical; the facing is modern. Our kitchen page lists both.
19. “All the texts put the Vastu Purusha’s head in the north-east”
- Usually traced to: the figure drawn on the mandala.
- What the text says: the Brihat Samhita lays him “with his face turned towards the ground and head in the north-east” (53.51). The Manasara summary puts his head in the central square of the east side, Surya’s square (chapter 7).
- Label: disputed. The texts disagree.
20. “The overhead water tank belongs in the south-west”
- Usually traced to: the idea that the south-west should be heavy.
- What the text says: the water verse gives water in the south-west “quarrels among women”, one of the results this site does not repeat as a forecast (53.119). The verse is about a pool on the ground, not a tank on a roof, and no verse on overhead tanks was found.
- Label: modern. Our water tanks page sets the two side by side.
Eight popular rules that the texts say
Fairness cuts both ways. These well-known rules are in the sources, close to how people repeat them.
| Rule people repeat | Where it is |
|---|---|
| The puja room in the north-east | Brihat Samhita 53.118 |
| The kitchen in the south-east | Brihat Samhita 53.118 |
| Do not sleep with the head to the north or west | Brihat Samhita 53.124 |
| Do not sleep under a beam | Brihat Samhita 53.124 |
| Keep the plot level | Brihat Samhita 53.116 |
| Water in the north or north-east is good | Brihat Samhita 53.119 |
| Thorny trees close to the house are not wanted | Brihat Samhita 53.86 |
| An image of Ganesha over the entrance | Manasara summary, chapter 39: images of Ganesha, Sarasvati and other deities carved over the entrance |
How to check a rule yourself
- Ask for the text, the chapter and the verse. A real citation can be looked up. Iyer’s translation of chapter 53 is free to read on wisdomlib.org, and Acharya’s summary of the Manasara is scanned on archive.org.
- Read the verse around it. Several verses above carry a condition in the next line.
- Ask what kind of building it is about. The Manasara treats temples, palaces, villages and houses separately; the Brihat Samhita opens with the king’s house (53.4).
- Compare two texts. A rule found in both is better established. Where they differ, as on the Vastu Purusha’s head, say so.
- If no verse comes, call it modern. That is a label, not an insult. Our method page uses the same three labels on every page: classical, modern, disputed.